Quick Answers
Can leaseholders form an RTM company in a mixed-use block?
Yes, provided the commercial floor space does not exceed 25% of the total internal floor area of the building. Above 25%, the right to manage is not available under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. This is a floor area calculation, not a unit count — one large restaurant on the ground floor of a smaller block can push the commercial proportion above the threshold.
Does the RTM company manage the commercial units?
No. The RTM company's management functions extend to the residential parts and the shared communal areas. The commercial units and their exclusive amenities remain the freeholder's responsibility. This split is one of the defining features of mixed-use block management and requires clear demarcation to avoid disputes about who is responsible for what.
How are service charges split between commercial and residential?
By the lease — each lease defines a service charge proportion, typically expressed as a fraction of the total or as a percentage derived from floor area. Commercial and residential units sharing communal areas typically contribute on a floor-area basis. Costs relating only to the residential or commercial parts are charged only to the relevant occupiers. The specific apportionment in any block is determined by reading each lease.
Why mixed-use blocks are more complex to manage: a purely residential block has one category of occupier, one category of lease, one service charge structure, and one managing agent responsible for the whole. A mixed-use block has two categories of occupier (residential leaseholders and commercial tenants), typically two categories of lease with different terms and different apportionment provisions, a service charge structure that must apportion costs between uses, and — where an RTM company has acquired management — a divided management responsibility where the RTM company manages the residential and shared elements while the freeholder retains management of the commercial units. Every one of these additional layers introduces potential for misunderstanding, dispute, and inadequate management if not actively handled.
The key principle: the starting point for resolving almost every question in a mixed-use block is the leases themselves. What does the residential lease say about the service charge proportion and the extent of the demise? What does the commercial lease say about the same? Where does the demise of each unit begin and end, and where does the common parts start? In many older mixed-use blocks in East London, the answers to these questions are not immediately obvious from the lease and require careful reading. Managing agents who do not read the leases before making apportionment decisions create disputes and sometimes breach the lease terms.
Key Takeaways
The 25% commercial floor area rule determines RTM eligibility
Where commercial floor space exceeds 25% of the total internal floor area of the building, leaseholders cannot acquire the right to manage under the 2002 Act. This is measured on internal floor area across all floors, not on the number of units or the proportion of service charge. A single large commercial unit in a small block can tip the balance past 25%. Where the RTM route is blocked by this rule, other routes — collective enfranchisement, appointment of a manager under the 1987 Act — may be available depending on the circumstances. Legal advice is essential before attempting any of these routes.
Read every lease before setting the service charge apportionment
In a mixed-use block with six residential flats and one commercial ground-floor unit, there are seven leases — and each one specifies the lessee's service charge proportion. These proportions are typically different for the commercial and residential units, and may have been calculated using different methodologies. Some older leases specify proportions that do not add up to 100% — either by design (where some costs are the freeholder's) or by error. The managing agent must read all leases and reconcile the apportionment structure before setting the service charge budget. Any shortfall or surplus in the apportionment must be identified and the lease position understood before charging begins.
The RTM company manages the shared areas, not the commercial unit
The RTM company's management remit in a mixed-use block is specific: the residential floors, the residential communal areas, and any communal areas shared between residential and commercial occupiers. The commercial units themselves — their internal maintenance, their exclusive facilities, their relationship with subtenants — remain the freeholder's responsibility. Where communal areas are shared (the main entrance lobby, for example, used by both residential leaseholders and customers of a ground-floor business), the cost of maintaining those shared areas is typically apportioned between residential and commercial occupiers based on usage or floor area, as defined in the leases.
Commercial use changes must be disclosed to the block's insurer
The block's buildings insurance must accurately reflect the uses taking place within the building. A commercial unit that changes use — from retail to restaurant, or from office to gym — changes the building's risk profile in ways that are material to the insurer. Failure to notify the insurer of a material change in use may entitle the insurer to avoid a claim or reduce a settlement. The managing agent should include in any commercial lease consent process a requirement that the insurer is notified of the change of use, and should review the insurance position each time a commercial unit changes hands or changes use.
Commercial tenants are not subject to the residential service charge legislation
The statutory protections that apply to residential service charges — the requirement for costs to be reasonably incurred, the right to a summary of costs, the right to inspect accounts, the right to apply to the First-tier Tribunal — derive from the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 and apply to dwellings. Commercial service charges are governed by the commercial lease terms and by general contract law, not by the residential service charge legislation. This means the RTM company has fewer statutory tools for managing a dispute with a commercial occupier than it would have with a residential leaseholder, and the commercial occupier has fewer statutory remedies if they dispute the service charge.
Building Safety Act obligations in mixed-use higher-risk buildings are complex
In mixed-use blocks that stand above 18 metres (or above seven storeys), the Building Safety Act 2022 creates a layered "accountable person" structure. Where the building has more than one accountable person — which is likely in a mixed-use building where the RTM company manages the residential parts and the freeholder manages the commercial parts — the Act requires these parties to cooperate and to agree how their respective obligations are discharged. The Building Safety Manager role, the safety case, and the building safety fund applications all need to reflect the mixed-use nature of the building. This is an area where specialist building safety advice is essential.
RTM Eligibility and the 25% Commercial Floor Area Rule
Under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, leaseholders can acquire the right to manage a building that includes commercial premises only where the non-residential floor space does not exceed 25% of the total internal floor area.
Key points on how this works in practice:
- The calculation is on total internal floor area — all floors of the building, both residential and commercial, measured internally. External areas (roof terraces, external car parks) are typically excluded.
- It is a floor area test, not a unit count test. A building with 40 flats and one large restaurant may still fail the 25% test if the restaurant occupies a significant ground floor footprint relative to the residential floors above.
- The calculation is carried out at the time the RTM company serves its claim notice on the freeholder. If the commercial floor area has changed since the RTM was originally acquired — for example, because a commercial unit has been extended or subdivided — the original eligibility determination may need to be revisited.
- Where the 25% threshold is borderline, professional measurement by a chartered surveyor using RICS measurement standards is advisable before the RTM claim is made — a disputed eligibility determination is expensive and delays the acquisition.
Where the commercial floor space exceeds 25% and RTM is not available, residential leaseholders may have other options: collective enfranchisement (buying the freehold collectively under the Leasehold Reform Housing and Urban Development Act 1993), or an application to the First-tier Tribunal for appointment of a manager under Section 24 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 where the freeholder has been mismanaging the building. Each route has its own eligibility criteria, process, and costs. Legal advice from a solicitor specialising in leasehold law is essential before proceeding.
Lease Structure in Mixed-Use Blocks
The critical difference between a residential lease and a commercial lease in the same block is not just the use permitted — it is the entire legal framework governing the relationship.
Residential leases
Long leasehold — typically 99–999 yearsCommercial leases
Shorter term — typically 5–25 yearsService Charge Apportionment in Mixed-Use Blocks
Service charge apportionment in a mixed-use block is one of the most frequently disputed aspects of block management. The starting point is always the specific lease wording for each unit. Common apportionment approaches found in East London mixed-use leases:
| Cost category | Typical apportionment approach |
|---|---|
| Structural maintenance and external fabric | Typically shared between all units (residential and commercial) on a floor-area basis. The external walls, roof, and foundations serve all occupiers and the cost is generally apportioned across all leases pro-rata by their internal floor area as a proportion of the total. |
| Shared communal areas (entrance lobby, shared lifts) | Apportioned between residential and commercial occupiers who actually use the relevant communal area. Where the main entrance lobby is shared between residential and commercial, the cost is typically split on a floor-area or usage basis. Where commercial occupiers have a separate entrance they use exclusively, they would not normally share in the cost of the residential lobby. |
| Residential-only communal areas (upper floor corridors, residential lifts) | Charged only to residential leaseholders. The commercial occupiers on the ground floor do not use the upper-floor residential corridors and should not be charged for their maintenance. Confirm the specific apportionment by reading the commercial and residential leases. |
| Commercial-only infrastructure (commercial extract, commercial refuse) | Where commercial occupiers have their own infrastructure that residential leaseholders do not use or benefit from, these costs should be charged only to the commercial units. A restaurant's commercial extract system or additional commercial refuse collection are typically commercial-only costs. |
| Buildings insurance | Typically shared across all units on a floor-area basis, since the insurance protects the whole building. However, where commercial uses significantly increase the insurance premium (food and beverage, for example), it is reasonable to explore whether the lease permits apportionment of the premium increment to the commercial units that drive the uplift. |
The Split Management Responsibility
Where an RTM company has acquired management of the residential elements of a mixed-use block, management responsibility is divided. Understanding exactly where the RTM company's responsibilities end and the freeholder's responsibilities begin is essential — and the dividing line is not always immediately obvious.
The general principle under the 2002 Act is that the RTM company takes over all management functions that the landlord would otherwise perform in relation to the premises — but only in relation to the residential parts and the communal areas. The freeholder retains responsibility for:
- The commercial units themselves — their internal maintenance, their structural condition if they are a separate demise from the rest of the building, and their tenant relationship
- Any building elements that are exclusively within or exclusively serving the commercial demise
- Enforcement of the commercial lease covenants against the commercial tenant
- Any consents required under the commercial lease (assignment, subletting, alterations)
The RTM company is responsible for:
- The residential flats and their associated communal areas
- Any communal areas shared between residential and commercial occupiers (and in these cases, must coordinate with the freeholder on cost apportionment)
- The external fabric of the building where it serves both residential and commercial parts
- Building safety compliance for the residential parts and shared areas
The areas of shared responsibility — the main entrance lobby, the lift serving both residential and commercial floors, the shared external terrace, the communal waste area — are where management disputes between RTM companies and freeholders most often arise. When an RTM company takes over management of a mixed-use block, one of the first priorities should be agreeing in writing with the freeholder which party is responsible for each shared element and how costs will be apportioned. This agreement does not change what the leases say, but it creates a practical working arrangement that prevents friction. Where a written agreement cannot be reached, legal advice on the lease interpretation should be sought before any ambiguous element is managed in a way that might conflict with the lease terms.
Insurance in Mixed-Use Buildings
Block buildings insurance for a mixed-use building is a specialist product and must accurately reflect every use taking place within the building.
Key differences from purely residential block insurance:
- Higher risk profile: commercial uses — particularly food and beverage, retail with public access, or healthcare — carry a higher fire, public liability, and business interruption risk profile than residential use alone. This affects premium levels and the specific coverages required.
- Public liability requirements: where members of the public access the building's communal areas to reach commercial tenants, the public liability coverage must reflect this. The standard residential block liability limits may be insufficient.
- Change of use notification: every time a commercial unit changes its use — from retail to restaurant, from office to gym — the insurer must be notified. This is a material change in the building's risk profile. The insurance broker should be consulted before any commercial use change takes effect, not after.
- Reinstatement cost assessment: the reinstatement cost for a mixed-use building must take account of the commercial fit-out where the freeholder is responsible for insuring it, or alternatively must confirm that the commercial tenant is responsible for insuring their own fit-out. This needs to be clear in the insurance documentation.
Common Issues in Mixed-Use Blocks and How to Handle Them
Noise and vibration from commercial use
A restaurant or bar with a kitchen extraction system, refrigeration units, or music creates noise and vibration that affects residential leaseholders directly above. Where the noise constitutes a breach of the commercial tenant's quiet enjoyment obligations to residential leaseholders or a breach of their lease covenants, the freeholder (as commercial landlord) must be pressed to enforce. Where the noise arises from the permitted use rather than a specific breach, environmental health authority involvement may be required.
Commercial waste in residential bins
A commercial tenant who deposits commercial waste in residential communal bins is both increasing waste costs for residential leaseholders and potentially causing the block to exceed its permitted waste volume. This is typically a breach of the commercial lease. Document it with photographs and written records, then write formally to the freeholder requiring enforcement against the commercial tenant under their lease terms.
Commercial deliveries blocking communal access
Early-morning deliveries to commercial units that block the communal entrance, lift access, or car park create disturbance and safety issues for residential leaseholders. Check whether the commercial lease contains any restrictions on delivery times or access routes. Where it does and they are being breached, enforcement lies with the freeholder. Where it does not, a practical approach — writing to the commercial tenant to propose agreed delivery windows — is often more effective than a legal one.
Commercial tenants using residential facilities
Commercial tenants who use the residential bin store, park in residential spaces, or use the residential entrance lobby as a storage area are typically in breach of their commercial lease. Document the behaviour, establish which lease clause is being breached, and write to the freeholder. Where the commercial lease does not clearly prohibit the behaviour, a practical agreement between the RTM company, the freeholder, and the commercial tenant is the most efficient resolution.
Service charge disputes with commercial tenants
Commercial tenants who dispute service charge apportionment have fewer statutory rights than residential leaseholders — their recourse is through their commercial lease terms and the county court. However, disputes about whether the apportionment is consistent with the lease are common and can be protracted. The most effective prevention is reading the leases carefully before setting the apportionment and documenting the lease basis for every allocation in the service charge accounts.
Unlicensed change of use by a commercial tenant
A commercial tenant who changes their use without obtaining the necessary planning permission (and without notifying the insurer) creates risk for the whole building. Where an RTM company becomes aware that a commercial unit has changed use without permission, they should notify the freeholder immediately in writing. The freeholder, as the commercial landlord, is responsible for enforcing the planning conditions and the lease use restriction against their commercial tenant.
For how the Building Safety Act accountable person structure applies to higher-risk mixed-use buildings, see Building Safety Act Compliance for Blocks. For how service charge apportionment disputes are resolved at the First-tier Tribunal, see First-tier Tribunal: Service Charge Disputes. For what to look for when appointing a managing agent with experience of mixed-use blocks, see Choosing a Block Managing Agent.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, provided the commercial floor space does not exceed 25% of the total internal floor area of the building. This is measured on internal floor area across all floors. Where commercial floor space exceeds 25%, the RTM route is not available under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. Where the threshold is borderline, have the floor areas measured professionally before making an RTM claim. Where RTM is blocked, other routes — collective enfranchisement or a Section 24 appointment of a manager — may be available depending on the circumstances.
By the specific terms of each lease. Each lease defines the lessee's service charge proportion — typically as a fraction of the total or a percentage derived from floor area. Costs relating to shared elements (external fabric, shared entrance, shared lift) are split between all occupiers who benefit. Costs relating only to the residential or commercial parts are charged only to the relevant occupiers. The managing agent must read all leases before setting the apportionment. In older mixed-use blocks, apportionment provisions are often inconsistent between leases and require careful reconciliation.
No. The RTM company's management functions under the 2002 Act extend only to the residential parts and the communal areas shared between residential and commercial occupiers. The commercial units themselves — internal maintenance, the commercial tenant relationship, lease enforcement — remain the freeholder's responsibility. This split is one of the most important things to understand in mixed-use block management. Where communal areas are shared, the RTM company and freeholder must coordinate on maintenance and cost apportionment.
Where the problem arises from a breach of the commercial tenant's lease — depositing waste in residential bins, using the residential entrance, exceeding permitted hours — enforcement lies with the freeholder as commercial landlord. The RTM company should document the issue and write formally to the freeholder requiring enforcement. If the freeholder fails to act, the RTM company can apply to the First-tier Tribunal. Where the problem arises from the permitted commercial use itself rather than a specific breach, options are more limited and may require environmental health authority involvement for statutory nuisance.
Yes. The presence of commercial uses — particularly food and beverage, retail with public access, or healthcare — changes the building's risk profile significantly. The insurer must be informed of all commercial uses. Any change in commercial use (a shop becoming a restaurant, for example) is a material change in risk that must be notified to the insurer. Failure to disclose commercial uses or changes in use may entitle the insurer to avoid a claim. Mixed-use block insurance is a specialist product and should be placed with an insurer who has experience of the specific combination of uses in the building.
Managing a mixed-use block where the commercial and residential sides are not properly coordinated?
Neon has experience managing mixed-use developments across East London — reading the leases correctly, setting the apportionment accurately, coordinating with freeholders on shared elements, and dealing with the commercial tenant issues that arise in practice. If your mixed-use block is being managed as if it were a purely residential one, talk to us.
Talk to Neon about your block →